Founding Attorney
When someone is arrested in Florida, emotions often run high. Fear, confusion, and anger can lead to split-second decisions that carry lasting consequences. One of the most common and damaging reactions during an arrest is resisting. Whether it’s pulling away from an officer’s grasp or verbally refusing commands, resisting arrest can create complications that extend far beyond the initial charge.
What Counts as Resisting Arrest in Florida?
Florida law makes it a crime to resist, obstruct, or oppose a law enforcement officer who is carrying out their legal duties. Resisting can take two forms:
- Resisting without violence (misdemeanor): refusing lawful commands, providing false information, or pulling away from an officer.
- Resisting with violence (felony): pushing, striking, or physically interfering with an officer during the arrest.
Even minor actions, such as stiffening your arms when being handcuffed, can result in a charge for resisting arrest. The severity of the penalty depends on whether violence was involved.
How Resisting Arrest Impacts Other Charges
Resisting arrest rarely stands alone. It often gets added to another underlying charge, such as DUI, theft, or assault. This can complicate the defense in several ways:
- Additional penalties: A resisting conviction adds fines, probation, or jail time on top of the original charge.
- Weakened credibility: Prosecutors may argue that resisting shows consciousness of guilt.
- Strained defense strategies: Resisting can distract from the defense of the main charge, shifting the focus to your behavior during the arrest rather than the facts of the alleged crime.
- Escalation of charges: What may have started as a misdemeanor offense can quickly rise to a felony if resisting with violence is alleged.
The Role of Police Conduct
Not all resisting charges are justified. Officers must follow proper procedures and respect your constitutional rights. If they used excessive force, lacked probable cause, or failed to clearly identify themselves, those facts may undermine the resisting charge. Part of your defense may involve scrutinizing the officer’s conduct as much as your own.
What to Do During an Arrest
The safest course of action is to avoid behaviors that could be considered resisting. While this is easier said than done in the heat of the moment, here are steps that can help protect you:
- Stay calm and do not argue. You can challenge the arrest later in court.
- Follow lawful instructions. Even if you believe the arrest is unjust, refusing commands can lead to added charges.
- Avoid physical resistance. Do not push, pull away, or attempt to flee.
- Exercise your rights. You have the right to remain silent and the right to request an attorney.
By maintaining composure, you reduce the risk of compounding your situation and preserve stronger grounds for your defense.
Why Having an Attorney Matters
Once resisting arrest is on the table, your case becomes more complex. Prosecutors may be less willing to negotiate, and judges may view your conduct as aggravating. At Van Elswyk Law, we understand how a single decision during an arrest can ripple across your entire case. We can review the officer’s actions, challenge the basis for the resisting charge, and build a defense strategy that addresses both the original accusation and the resisting allegation. Our goal is to minimize the long-term consequences and protect your rights at every stage of the process.
Protecting Your Defense Starts Now
Resisting arrest can quickly turn a difficult situation into a much more serious one. The best way to protect yourself is to comply in the moment, then fight the charges with the help of an attorney who knows how Florida courts handle these cases.
If you or a loved one has been accused of resisting arrest, contact Van Elswyk Law. We are here to provide clear guidance, strong representation, and the support you need to move forward.
Frequently Asked Questions About Resisting Arrest in Florida
Can I be charged with resisting arrest even if I didn’t use force?
Yes. Florida law allows officers to charge you with resisting arrest without violence for actions like refusing commands, giving false information, or pulling away during handcuffing. You do not need to use physical force for prosecutors to pursue this charge.
Does resisting arrest make my original charge harder to fight?
It often does. Prosecutors may use resisting as evidence that you knew you were guilty of the underlying crime. It also creates additional charges and penalties, which can limit options for plea deals or dismissal.
How can a lawyer help with a resisting arrest charge?
A criminal defense attorney can examine whether the officer acted lawfully, challenge the basis for the resisting allegation, and work to reduce or dismiss the charge. They will also develop a defense strategy that considers both the resisting count and the original offense.